Guide for Our Return to Public Gatherings. Our COVID-19 Restrictions
Read more

Supreme Court rules that states cannot discriminate against religious schools by withholding financial aid

By:

In a 5-4 ruling upholding a Montana program to provide student scholarships for use at religious schools, the Supreme Court also in effect repudiated a 19th-century monument to anti-Catholic bigotry known as the Blaine Amendment.

The majority opinion in the case, announced Tuesday, was written by Chief Justice John Roberts, joined by Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch, and Brett Kavanaugh. Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor, and Elena Kagan dissented.

Referring to the Montana constitution’s version of the Blaine Amendment, Roberts wrote, “The application of the no-aid provision discriminated against religious schools and the families whose children attend or hope to attend them in violation of the Free Exercise Clause of the federal Constitution.”

The Supreme Court ruling reversed a 2018 decision by the Montana Supreme Court based on the state constitution’s Blaine provision barring aid to any school “controlled in whole or in part by any church, sect or denomination.”

The Montana case (Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue) concerned a scholarship program enacted by the state legislature in 2015. The program provided a tax credit of up to $150 annually to individuals and businesses donating to private organizations established to receive the donations and disburse the money to families with children in nonpublic schools.

The only such organization set up to date awarded scholarships only to low-income families or families whose children have disabilities. Shortly after enactment of the program, the state revenue department adopted an administrative rule barring use of scholarships at religious schools. In doing so, it cited Montana’s Blaine Amendment.

That provision is named for U.S. Representative and Senator James Blaine, who in the 1870s argued for an amendment to the U.S. Constitution to bar use of public funds at religious schools. Coming at a time when immigration was rapidly increasing the Catholic population and Catholic parochial schools were growing in number, the proposal was widely seen as a reflection of Protestant anxieties about rising Catholic numbers and influence.

While Blaine never did become part of the federal Constitution, 37 states, with Montana among them, eventually adopted their own versions.

In a statement following the decision, Archbishop Thomas G. Wenski of Miami, chairman of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ Committee for Religious Liberty, and Bishop Michael C. Barber of Oakland, California, chairman of the Committee on Catholic Education, said: “The Court has rightly ruled that the U.S. Constitution does not permit states to discriminate against religion. This decision means that religious persons and organizations can, like everyone else, participate in government programs that are open to all. This is good news, not only for people of faith, but for our country. A strong civil society needs the full participation of religious institutions. By ensuring the rights of faith-based organizations’ freedom to serve, the court is also promoting the common good.”

In striking down Montana’s Blaine Amendment, the bishops said, “The court has also dealt a blow to the odious legacy of anti-Catholicism in America. … [The amendments] were never meant to ensure government neutrality toward religion, but were expressions of hostility toward the Catholic Church. We are grateful that the Supreme Court has taken an important step that will help bring an end to this shameful legacy.”

The plaintiffs in the Montana case were three low-income mothers who said they counted on assistance from the scholarship program to send their children to a Christian school. The state Supreme Court’s decision dealt with the dispute by eliminating the state’s scholarship program entirely.

In his majority opinion, Roberts relied heavily on a 2017 Supreme Court decision (Trinity Lutheran Church v. Comer) that held that a Lutheran church in Missouri that operated a day school was entitled to receive funds from a state program for upgrading playgrounds as a safety measure.

In that decision, Roberts said, the Supreme Court held that “disqualifying otherwise eligible recipients from a public benefit ‘solely because of their religious character’ imposes a penalty” on religious free exercise. By that standard, he held, Montana’s denial of scholarships for use at a religious school did not pass muster.

This article comes to you from OSV Newsweekly (Our Sunday Visitor) courtesy of your parish or diocese.

 

Catholic News & Perspective

Provides information on the Church, the nation and the world from OSV, America's most popular and trusted national Catholic news source


Recent

COVID-19 changes campus classes, dining halls, dorms and maybe fees

Wednesday, August 5, 2020
By: Carol Zimmermann WASHINGTON (CNS) — The fall semester at Catholic colleges and universities around the country will look and feel very... Read More

The mission of prayer is at the heart of hope

Monday, August 3, 2020
By: Kathryn Jean Lopez One of the most powerful places in our nation’s capital has very little to do with government, or lobbyists, or... Read More

Opening the Word: Suffering and sacrifice

Friday, July 31, 2020
By: Timothy P. O'Malley Feeding miracles are prominent in each of the Gospels. On five occasions in the Gospels, Jesus takes a small quantity of... Read More

Priests find ways to manage stress, pastoral duties amid virus resurgence

Wednesday, July 29, 2020
By: Brian Fraga Wearing his personal protective gear, Father Chris Ponnet said he “feels extremely safe” while he’s anointing the... Read More

Will they know we are Christians?

Monday, July 27, 2020
By: Ava Lalor Ever since summer began, my young adult group has been planning different ways to get together. We’ve taken advantage... Read More

Opening the Word: ‘Do you understand all these things?’

Friday, July 24, 2020
By: Timothy P. O'Malley In the Gospel of Matthew, Jesus tells parables in groups of three. The parables, while building off one another, are... Read More

New survey of bishops details financial impact of COVID-19 pandemic on dioceses, parishes

Wednesday, July 22, 2020
By: Brian Fraga The vast majority of the nation’s Catholic bishops say the novel coronavirus pandemic has upended the life of their local... Read More

What Americans can learn from the Canadian school system

Monday, July 20, 2020
By:  Msgr. Owen F. Campion The recent United States Supreme Court decision regarding religious schools brings to mind a basic... Read More

Opening the Word: Opening the Word: Another virus, and the wheat and the weeds

Friday, July 17, 2020
By: Timothy P. O'Malley Dear friends, there is a virus circulating not only in the world but also in the Church. This virus cultivates... Read More

As new Missionary of Mercy, South Carolina priest focuses his ministry on the hope of God’s love

Wednesday, July 15, 2020
By: Brian Fraga People joke about what a disaster 2020 has been, but Americans could be forgiven for being tempted to despair after the first six... Read More

Online Giving

Online Giving

Secure and Convenient Donate now!